Boehner Doubts Immigration Bill Will Pass in 2014

WASHINGTON — The yearlong effort to overhaul the nation’s immigration laws, which had the support of President Obama, Republican leaders and much of American business and labor, was seriously imperiled on Thursday when Speaker John A. Boehner conceded that it was unlikely he could pass a bill.

His pronouncement, amid mounting resistance from conservatives, significantly narrowed the window for success this year and left it to Mr. Obama to win the trust of balking Republicans.

Mr. Boehner’s remarks came a week after he and other House Republican leaders offered a statement of principles intended to win support for the measure. But, he said, House Republicans are not prepared to move forward in partnership with a Democratic administration that they believe will not fairly and impartially carry out the laws they pass.

“The American people, including many of my members, don’t trust that the reform that we’re talking about will be implemented as it was intended to be,” said Mr. Boehner of Ohio, citing executive actions by the Obama administration that have changed or delayed the carrying out of the president’s health care law.

At their most optimistic, the speaker’s words put the drive for immigration legislation in abeyance until tempers cool, some advocates in Congress said. But lawmakers on both sides of the issue conceded that the politics had turned sharply negative in recent days.

Tea Party activists have shifted their focus from cutting the federal budget deficit to thwarting what they call amnesty for those in the country illegally. Conservative groups have called for a clean sweep of the Republican leadership. One House member openly suggested that a drive now for comprehensive immigration legislation should cost Mr. Boehner his job.

While reiterating his personal support for addressing the nation’s faltering laws to control the border, admit immigrants and workers, and handle the 11 million people in the country illegally, Mr. Boehner lamented, “I’ve never underestimated the difficulty in moving forward this year.”

Senator Jeff Sessions, Republican of Alabama, who organized opposition in the House toward the leadership’s immigration push, said Mr. Boehner’s comments were “a recognition of reality.” “Obviously, the speaker had some goal to try to do something,” Mr. Sessions said, “but we were too far apart on substance to ever realistically expect an agreement with the Democrats.”

Republican divisions are so deep, Mr. Sessions said, “it wouldn’t end well in any circumstance, so that was the only decision he could make.”

Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina and a leading negotiator of the Senate’s sweeping immigration legislation, blamed the toxic fallout from the fight over the Affordable Care Act. Mr. Obama’s promises since his State of the Union address to use his phone and his pen to wield executive power when Congress will not act has soured some Republicans who might have been persuaded to move forward.

“One of the casualties of Obamacare is it makes it hard for politicians to do big things,” Mr. Graham said. “They’re complicated to administer, and the president has shown a willingness to unilaterally change provisions that are politically harmful.”

The White House press secretary, Jay Carney, rejected the notion that the president had been an untrustworthy negotiating partner on immigration. His efforts to bolster border security and enforce immigration laws have angered many of the immigration advocates who back him on his legislative effort.

“The challenges within the Republican Party on this issue are well known, and they certainly don’t have anything to do with the president,” he said, praising the Republican leadership for the progress it had made.

But that leadership appears to have made a sharp reversal. The speaker’s comments came two days after Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Senate Republican leader, cited “irresolvable conflict” between the House and the Senate and said, “I don’t see how you get to an outcome this year with the two bodies in such a different place.”

Mr. McConnell’s office had given aides to the speaker a warning that he would say that, and senior House Republican aides said Thursday that the two leaders did not disagree.

Even Republicans modestly supportive of immigration legislation have said this election year is not the time to move forward. Doing so, they say, would only splinter the party and detract from the attention Republican candidates are trying to focus on the troubled rollout of Mr. Obama’s health care law and his sagging approval ratings. By casting the issue as one of trust in the president, Mr. Boehner tried to lay the blame at the White House’s feet for what appears to be a quickly flagging immigration push.

“The reason I said we need a step-by-step common-sense approach to this is so we can build trust with the American people that we’re doing this the right way,” Mr. Boehner said. “And, frankly, one of the biggest obstacles we face is the one of trust.”

At their retreat in Maryland last week, many Republicans rejected outright the House leadership’s one-page “standards for immigration reform.” Others said that, with trends going their way as midterm elections approach, it was a bad time to take on a number of contentious issues.

Read more:

Revilla Law Firm, P.A., is a Miami immigration firm that handles cases in all areas of immigration law. Antonio G. Revilla III is a Former U.S. Prosecutor and an immigration attorney with over 22 years of legal experience. Mr. Revilla is also the President of the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA), South Florida Chapter, and a passionate advocate for immigration reform. Contact Revilla Law Firm today for a free in-office consultation with one of our immigration attorneys (305) 858-2323 or (877) 854-2323.